Literature · Culture

On Kashmiriyat outside of Kashmir

Sukhmani Khorana offers a poignant reflection on the enduring spirit of Kashmir's syncretic culture through her diasporic Sikh lens, finding traces of Kashmiriyat's composite harmony in memory, childhood streets, and the hope for renewed coexistence beyond political binaries.

On Kashmiriyat outside of Kashmir
Mubarak Mandi Palace - Seat of erstwhile Dogra rulers of Jammu

I am still too stunned to speak of the violence, the reprisal, the counters and encounters that pause but don’t stop.
Too Sikh to take sides
Too diasporic to have a stake
Of the land but not of the binaries…
Hindu-Muslim, Kashmiri-Dogra, For or Against, Secular or Nationalist.

I’m told that Kashmiriyat is officially Dead.
That it was a political invention anyway.
I also hear that it was real in the Sufi music schools,
In the composite culture of phirans, festivals, folklore.
Not without schisms
Not live side-by-side and trot-out-your-culture on Harmony Day.
But syncretic
And alive.
And sometimes revived.

I haven’t been back since I was a teenager
So how can I transcend this hearsay?
Yet I know it was alive where I went to school in Jammu
And alive on the street I grew up in Which still houses an Idgah, a Catholic school, and the headquarters on the National Conference party
While being metres away from Raghunath Mandir.
This wasn’t mere coexistence or tolerance.
There was reciprocity, respect and witnessing.
The lived reality that makes me crave for a deeper multiculturalism where I am today.

Kashmiriyat is alive in the memories of those who lived through it
In the hearts those who still believe in it
And in the minds of those like me who grew up with its residues and its ashes.

I don’t know what governments and non-state actors in the region are capable of.
I know only that the region has done better.
I recall times when explosions were seen as divisive.
I remember people not taking the bait and turning on their neighbours.
It later dawned on me that resentments were harboured and unleashed when encouraged to come out en masse behind screens.
And I still held on to hope that this was a mere pause.
Because a fragile peace is perhaps better than a cold peace.
And Kashmiriyat Now will mean new things and new ways and new memes.

Found an error? Tell our editors.
About the author

Sukhmani Khorana

Sukhmani Khorana was born in Jammu, India and has lived in Australia for over two decades. She is an academic at UNSW by trade and a writer and public scholar by vocation.

More stories by Sukhmani Khorana
Continue reading
Next in Opinion

East of Empire: partitioning of India and Palestine unleashed the violent conflict that continues today

How the bold, hopeful visions of self-determination in Britain’s eastern colonies curdled into a more militant nationalism by the end of the second world war.

Read next
The Friday Brief

One email. The week that mattered for Indians abroad.

Essential news, practical policy updates and the strongest reporting from across the diaspora.

No noise. Unsubscribe whenever you like.
WP Twitter Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com