A £350,000 home can require £2,500, £7,500 or £25,000 in Stamp Duty Land Tax under three different ownership scenarios in England. The purchase price has not changed. The buyer’s eligibility for relief and existing property interests have.
For a British Indian household deciding whether to rent or buy, that difference can matter more than a small gap between monthly rent and a mortgage payment. A home inherited in India may affect the calculation even if the family has never bought a British property.
The worked example below uses explicitly assumed figures, not an interviewed family, a live mortgage offer or a claim about average market prices. Its purpose is to make the comparison reproducible. Tax rules were checked on 21 November 2026. The transaction-tax examples apply to England, rather than the whole UK.
Which figures should a rent or buy comparison include?
Compare the cash required, the costs that are consumed and the equity retained, using the same period and comparable homes.
A mortgage payment combines interest and repayment of the loan. Rent does not create ownership equity, but a renter may retain money that a buyer commits to the deposit and transaction. Treating the entire mortgage payment as a permanent cost, or ignoring the deposit’s alternative uses, distorts the comparison.
MoneyHelper’s mortgage-cost guide identifies additional buying, financing and moving expenses. Obtain quotes rather than copying a national average into a particular family’s budget. The amount and timing of fees can change the cash needed before completion.
Decide what the comparison is measuring. “Can we afford the monthly payment?” is different from “Which choice leaves us with more wealth after five years?” A household may reasonably prefer flexibility or housing stability even when a simplified financial model points elsewhere.
What assumptions does this five-year scenario use?
The model assumes a £350,000 freehold home, a £70,000 deposit and a £280,000 repayment mortgage over 25 years.
The interest rate is an assumed 4.5% a year, calculated monthly and held constant for the full five-year comparison. The assumed alternative rent is £1,500 a month, also unchanged. These are modelling inputs, not statements about available rates or local rents.
The model assumes £200 a month is spent on maintenance and £30 on buildings insurance. Any unused maintenance reserve would remain the household’s asset. Those are assumptions, not quotes. The model assumes no service charge or ground rent because it uses a freehold example. A leasehold purchase requires its actual charges and planned major works to be added.
| Input | Explicit assumption |
|---|---|
| Purchase price | £350,000 |
| Deposit | £70,000 |
| Repayment loan | £280,000 |
| Loan term | 25 years |
| Annual interest rate | 4.5% |
| Comparable rent | £1,500 monthly |
| Maintenance allowance | £200 monthly |
| Buildings insurance | £30 monthly |
| Comparison period | 60 months |
Council tax, utilities and contents insurance are excluded from both sides on the assumption that they are identical. That does not mean they are free. If the homes differ in size, efficiency or location, insert the actual difference before comparing them.

How much of the mortgage payment becomes equity?
At the assumed rate, the monthly repayment is approximately £1,556.33, and about £33,997.87 of the original loan is repaid after 60 payments.
The calculation uses the standard repayment formula: monthly payment equals loan multiplied by the monthly interest rate, divided by one minus the discount factor over 300 payments. Calculations retain full precision internally; displayed amounts are rounded to pennies.
Over five years, mortgage payments total approximately £93,379.86. About £59,381.99 is interest and £33,997.87 repays principal, leaving a loan balance of approximately £246,002.13. Small differences can occur in an actual lender’s daily-interest and payment calculations.
If the property price stayed at £350,000, equity before selling costs would be approximately £103,997.87: the original deposit plus the principal repaid. That money is tied to the property. It is not an emergency cash balance available without another transaction or borrowing decision.
What is an unrecoverable housing cost?
It is spending that does not itself become an ownership asset, such as rent, mortgage interest, transaction tax or maintenance. A deposit and principal repayments need different treatment because they contribute to equity, although that equity can lose value.
What does the first-time-buyer tax assumption change?
The base case assumes every purchaser qualifies for first-time-buyer relief, occupies the property as a main home and is not subject to the non-resident surcharge.
Under the current residential SDLT rates, eligible first-time buyers pay no SDLT on the first £300,000 and 5% on the remaining £50,000 of this £350,000 purchase. That produces £2,500. The relief is unavailable if the price exceeds £500,000.
The model also assumes £2,000 for legal work, £600 for a survey, £1,000 in mortgage fees and £500 for moving. These four illustrative allowances total £4,100. Added to £2,500 SDLT, they give £6,600 in upfront costs excluding the deposit.
Replace each allowance with a written quote and check what is included. Citizens Advice’s buying guide distinguishes conveyancing, searches, lender charges and other purchase expenses. Some costs can still be incurred if a transaction fails.
How can a home in India affect the SDLT bill?
Previous ownership of a qualifying dwelling interest anywhere in the world can prevent first-time-buyer relief, including an interest acquired by inheritance or gift.
That is the rule in HMRC’s first-time-buyer definition. Where purchasers buy jointly, all must meet the conditions. “My first purchase in Britain” is therefore not the same tax statement as “I am an eligible first-time buyer”.
If the buyer does not qualify for relief but the standard single-property rates apply, SDLT on £350,000 is £7,500. If the higher additional-property rates apply throughout, it is £25,000. These are different scenarios, not alternative estimates for one legally identical purchase.
| SDLT scenario on £350,000 | Tax | Difference from base case |
|---|---|---|
| Eligible first-time-buyer relief | £2,500 | £0 |
| Standard residential rates | £7,500 | £5,000 |
| Higher additional-property rates | £25,000 | £22,500 |
The additional-property rules contain ownership, value, spouse and replacement-home provisions. A small inherited share or a previous sale requires its own assessment. Ask the conveyancer which scenario actually applies; do not infer the answer from a family surname or nationality.

What is the five-year result before investment returns or price changes?
In the simplified first-time-buyer case, buying uses approximately £23,779.86 more cash than renting, excluding the deposit, while repaying approximately £33,997.87 of principal.
Five years of rent total £90,000. Buying requires approximately £93,379.86 in loan payments, £13,800 in assumed maintenance and buildings insurance, and £6,600 in initial costs. That totals £113,779.86, excluding the £70,000 deposit.
Subtract the principal repaid from that total and the buyer’s modelled unrecoverable costs are approximately £79,781.99. This is £10,218.01 below the assumed rent. It is a partial accounting result, not proof that buying is the better investment.
The comparison has deliberately not assigned a return to the renter’s retained £70,000 deposit or the monthly cash difference. It also excludes property-price changes and eventual selling costs. Those omissions can change the conclusion, particularly over a short ownership period.
If the £25,000 SDLT scenario applies, replacing the base-case tax adds £22,500. Modelled buying costs then exceed the assumed rent even before allowing for investment returns or selling. The ownership-history question is therefore part of the financial model, not a form to complete afterwards.
How sensitive is the household budget to interest rates?
The same £280,000 loan over 25 years produces materially different payments when the assumed rate changes.
| Assumed annual rate | Approximate monthly repayment |
|---|---|
| 3.5% | £1,401.75 |
| 4.5% | £1,556.33 |
| 5.5% | £1,719.44 |
| 6.5% | £1,890.58 |
These figures recalculate a new loan at each constant rate. They do not predict a lender’s future offer or the exact payment when a fixed period ends. Use the remaining balance and remaining term for an actual refinancing calculation.
Ask the lender or broker about the initial product period, fees, reversion rate, overpayments and early-repayment charges. MoneyHelper’s mortgage application guidance explains affordability checks. The amount offered by a lender and the amount a household is comfortable paying can differ.

What should a British Indian household check beyond the spreadsheet?
Check the expected length of stay, employment resilience, property condition and Indian ownership records before deciding.
A possible move between countries changes the practical value of flexibility. Ask what happens if the home must be sold earlier than planned, rented out with the lender’s permission or maintained from abroad. Do not assume a mortgage product automatically permits letting.
For leasehold homes, replace the freehold assumptions with actual service charges, lease details and major-works information. For the rented alternative, check the tenancy, deposit arrangements and likely moving costs. Compare homes that meet the same household needs rather than a small rental with a larger purchase.
Indian property can also raise separate estate questions, addressed in the UK inheritance-tax guide. That does not determine SDLT or make one ownership structure suitable for every household.
What happens next?
Obtain a local rent comparison, a mortgage illustration, a conveyancing quote and a written SDLT assessment, then rerun the scenario with those figures.
Keep a version of the model showing every assumption and exclusion. Use the business section for related financial explainers, and recheck the tax rules at the planned completion date. The useful outcome is a decision the household can explain, including the risks it is willing to carry.
